Thursday, June 6, 2013

Commentary on the Charge of the Goddess 36: And thou who thinkest to seek me...



And thou who thinkest to seek me; Know that thy seeking and yearning shall avail thee not unless thou know the mystery, that if that which thou seekest thou findest not within thee; Thou wilt never find it without thee. For behold; I have been with thee from the begining, and I am that which is attained at the end of desire.
Sources and Influences
BAM: And if thou sayest, I have journied unto thee, and it availed me not, Rather shalt thou say, I called upon thee, and I waited patiently, and Lo, Thou wast with me from the beginning For they that ever desired me, shall ever attain me, even to the end of all desire.

Cro. LXV: But I have called unto Thee, and I have journied unto Thee, and it availed me not. I waited patiently, and thou wast with me from the beginning. (2.59-60)

‘Alipilli’ cited in L.A. Cahagnet, Magnetic Magic, 1898:[1] That if that which thou seekest thou findest not within thee; thou wilt never find it without thee.

Cro. LXV: They that ever desired Thee shall obtain Thee, even at the End of their Desire. (3.63)

Thealogy
This final part of the Charge returns to the important theme of the presence of the Goddess within the witch, and the nature of the witch’s search for her. For the Wiccan nature of the search for the Goddess and its end are both contained in the realisation that she is already within, reminiscent of the maxim found in the mystery religions and subsequent occult traditions: ‘Know thyself,’ concluding the Charge’s journey inwards to the revelation that the journey ends within.
The understanding of knowing ourselves must inevitably be coloured by the event of greater understanding in psychology and psychoanalysis from the nineteenth century onwards. Dion Fortune is an example of an occultist who united the understandings of traditional occultism and of modern psychology. The Gods and Goddesses can even be seen as representative of forces within, which is not necessarily to denigrate their existence as genuine powers in the world, but can aid in the understanding of these powers, as Tau Allen Greenfield writes:

‘True occult initiates have always regarded the Ultimate Reality as beyond all names and description. Named “deities” are, therefore, largely symbols. “Isis” is a symbol of the long-denied female component of deity to some occultists. “Pan” or “The Horned God” or “Set” or even “Satan” are symbols of unconscious, repressed sexuality. To the occultist, there is no Devil, no “god of evil.” There is, ultimately, only the Ain Sof Aur of the Qabala: the limitless light of which we are but a frozen spark. Evil, in this system, is the mere absence of light. All else is illusion.
‘The goal of the occult path of initiation is balance. In Freemasonry and High Magick, the symbols of the White Pillar and Black Pillar represent this balance between conscious and unconscious forces.’[2]


The Goddess may be seen, returning to the idea of the collective unconscious, as something which exists as a symbol in the collective unconscious of humanity, which is why she seems familiar to us and may be related to the concept of morphic resonance mentioned above. Interpreting the Great Mother as a Jungian archetype may appear to resolve the problem of the ahistoricity of this idea, but in its turn it creates a different sort of history. That is, in looking back at the existence of what we can now understand as an archetype, we undertake an essentially modern search, and once again may be imposing modern ideas on historical images. However Neumann writes that in seeking for a psychological understanding of the Great Mother this may be inevitable:

‘If we offend against “history” by removing documents and representations from their cultural context, we hope to compensate by correlating our archetypal investigation with a “psychohistory,” that is to say, with the stages in the development of the human psyche. Taking the development of consciousness as the decisive phenomena of human history, we arrive at an arrangement of the phenomena that does not, to be sure, coincide with the usual sequence of historical events, but makes possible the psychological orientation we require.’[3]


The journey within for the witch mirrors the Goddess’s descent to death and ascent, and is embodied in the initiations. Vivianne Crowley, who has perhaps the most psychological understanding of the Wiccan mysteries of published writers, believes inner transformation - with magical techniques and a Goddess religion – to be one of three facets found in Wicca.[4] She understands the Wiccan initiation both to cause entry into a particular coven or tradition and into the priestly, magical and mystical ‘current’ of Wicca, which she equates to renovatio, one of the forms of rebirth identified by Jung. [5]
In the first degree initiation, Crowley identifies the significance of being skyclad as signifying how we come into the world, as related to the rebirth of the initiation. The psychological aspects of initiation she relates to a meditation in which the candidate is asked to identify aspects of the personality she wishes to strengthen or weaken, with the elements. In the ritual of elements balancing undertaken before the initiation, the candidate is taken on an inner journey through her own elements, which Crowley likens to the candidate invoking the elemental quarters of her own personality; she states this is necessary because normally when the circle is cast the elements are balanced by the callings, but at an initiation the candidate is outside the circle when it is cast. The binding of the candidate represents the state of the candidate before initiation for Crowley: she is still bound to matter, and is not yet freed by initiation for her spiritual journey.
Crowley likens the challenge to the candidate to that made by the guardian of the candidate’s unconscious: passing through this gateway allows the candidate to face all that is unconscious about herself and face her shadows and fears. In the first degree initiation, the initiate is enabled to make the journey inwards to face these things (and also face the Goddess, since it is within that we must find her), in a position of vulnerability and weakness, and to progress from that position to develop magical ability and insight.
Enabled to do this work, the initiate can develop towards second degree initiation, frequently marked in Wicca by the ability to teach and initiate others. Crowley understands the much-misunderstood symbol of second degree initiation, the pentagram with two points uppermost, in psychological terms. The spirit point is at the bottom, underneath the points for the four elements, since spirit has emerged for the candidate, but is not yet master over the others. Discovering what is hidden is necessary for the pentagram to be turned over, with the spirit point at its rightful top position, at third degree initiation.
By the second degree initiation, the candidate, initiated in the first degree should have begun to recognise and sort out his ‘stuff’. In Crowley’s psychological understanding, second degree initiation is what enables a meeting between the Ego and the shadow side of our personality, the unconscious: another appearance of the motif of reconciliation of opposites, since the two sides of the personality have been likened to dark and light, male and female.
Second degree initiation brings the initiate into the succession of witches: the initiator doesn’t only will his own power into her, but connects her to the power of all witches, marking the initiate permanently as a witch, both in this and future incarnations. Crowley comments that initiation of the second degree can be a very lonely time for the witch, forced to rely on her own resources, which can frequently be a time of disillusionment with the human frailties of her initiators (compare with Farrar and Bone’s ‘Second Degree Syndrome’ mentioned above).
The theme of descent appears at second degree initiation, and Crowley once again interprets this in psychological terms. For a man, she sees the significance of the descent at second degree as being meeting his own anima, leading to reconciliation between his male and female personalities. For a woman, the journey is embodied in the Goddess’s journey into the underworld to meet the Dread Lord of Death, who represents the kingdom of the unconscious mind, signifying the woman’s animus, or male aspect. For both men and women, this leads to a meeting within aspects of their personalities: for this a journey is required, it cannot just happen, and this meeting is preparatory to the marriage between the two sides of the personality, which will happen at third degree, and is embodied in the Great Rite of Wicca.
Crowley understands the third degree initiation to recognise a certain level of development within the candidate, in which the seat of understanding is moving from the Ego to the Self, marked by the lessening of inner conflicts. This degree is celebrated in the Great Rites, which Crowley equates to the Heiros Gamos – or sacred marriage – of ancient Paganism, in which the participants are reborn as sacred twins. Crowley contrasts this Pagan approach to sexuality, in which one is merged with another, with the Christian approach, in which she states sexuality is ‘transmuted within the individual to achieve a higher state of consciousness.’[6]
While the externals of the third degree initiation consist of a sacred union of the Goddess and God invoked into the priestess and priest, Crowley sees the inner significance of this rite to be the union of the Jungian Ego with the Anima or Animus so that the Self may be born. In this psychological understanding of the rite, this union takes place and has its fruit inwardly. In this interpretation the third degree opens the way for the reconciliation of the conflicting aspects of the initiate’s personality:

‘The inner marriage is the marriage of soul and spirit, Ego and Self, and leads to individuation. It is the opening of the secret way by the few which will lead to the opening of the way for the many. The unconscious is like a jungle. Its paths must be hacked through with great effort and then kept open by continual use. ...
‘...our lives can be considered a sacred quest. It is a quest which may have begun in this lifetime or many lifetimes before. It is a quest to find ourselves: who and what we really are. To do this we must first cease to pretend to be what we are not. We must cast away our Persona or mask. We must be prepared to confront the Shadow, that which we are and would rather we were not. Only then can we unify our conscious and unconscious minds and so give birth to the hidden Sun – the Self.’[7]


Crowley writes that the three degrees of initiation in Wicca can represent the stages of this process. Although this degree is analogous to the process of inidividuation, she writes that it may involve even more inner turmoil because of its quality of sacrifice. Individuation of the self involves clear differentiation from others, and the third degree Wiccan’s role of caring for others can mean making decisions on when to accede or not to the relentless demands which others may make.
This journey ends with meeting the archetype of the Wise Old Man (or Woman), who represents our true self; Crowley equates this to the concept of the knowledge and conversation of one Holy Guardian Angel in ceremonial magic. From this point on, the person is wholly reliant on inner wisdom, because the person has become her true self, and Crowley sees the initiation rites of Wicca as opening the gates within the self which can enable this to happen. The instruction which Crowley quotes from the rite strikingly parallels the creation myth of the Feri tradition quoted above:

‘Ere time began the One who is all looked inward on itself and beheld itself as though through a reflection in a pool and so came to self-awareness. And in that coming to self-awareness, the One was made two, subject and object; that which looks and that which is looked upon; and it divided from itself. And as the One was made Two, so the male and the female were made separate.
‘And it came to pass that the Two who had come from the One sought to be joined together and made whole again. And so shall the male and the female be joined as One and from that union with the other who is in truth but part of the Self, the doubt and the fear which are the product of the delusion of solitude shall be banished.’[8]


Truly, she has been within us from the beginning, the search starts within and ends within. In a sense the search for the Goddess of the witches finds its end in abandoning the search: when you no longer seek the Goddess you have found her. This relates to the magical practice of forgetting about work in progress, as stated above the reason is that turning over your intent in your mind calls it back to you and prevents it happening. Similarly forgetting about the search for the Goddess allows to come to mind the Goddess who is all things.
This thealogy differentiates Wicca from the New Age movements, with which it is often compared, and in which the emphasis is more on seeking human potential. In Wicca there is no further potential to be achieved, or rather no further potential to be sought outside the individual, because humans already have the fullness of their potential within them, the Goddess is within, she is also everything, and her influence can been seen and engaged with through the ‘correspondences’ of our lives.


[1] Cited in Kelly, 2007, p. 185.
[2] Tau Allen Greenfield: The Secret History of Modern Witchcraft. In Richard Metzger (editor): Book of Lies: The Disinformation Guide to Magick and the Occult. Disinformation Company, New York, 2009, p. 267.
[3] Erich Neumann: The Great Mother. Pantheon Books, New York, 1955, p. 89.
[4] Interview in Michael Jordan: Witches: An Encyclopedia of Paganism and Magic. Kyle Cathie Ltd, London, 2000.
[5] Vivianne Crowley: Wicca: The Old Religion in the New Millenium (Revised and Updated). Thorsons, London, 1996.
[6] Ibid, p. 222.
[7] Ibid, p. 223.
[8] Ibid, p. 228.

No comments:

Post a Comment

All comments are moderated before publication